A new assessment of students in French will be implemented in CE2 classes in primary education following the announcement of the Minister of National Education, Najat Vallaud Belkacem. In the street, at the end of a school, the parents of pupils are rather dubious on these umpteenth tests. Interview with Sébastien Sihr, Syndicat SNUIPP: "Setting up a new thermometer has never been able to treat fever. The minister needs to tell us what she intends to do before the third grade when teachers need fewer students per class to teach them how to read. And what she plans to implement after identifying children in difficulty."
Back on the famous evaluations within the primary school. Since yesterday, CM2 students are working in mathematics and French. Tests of level set up in 2009 and very criticized by teachers and some federations of parents of pupils. Problems of pedagogical usefulness, stress of the examination for the pupils, and especially use of the data, the unions do not lack grievances concerning these evaluations. Again this year, many teachers have planned not to pass on the results to their hierarchy.
Until Friday, the 21,000 students of CM2 of Picardie pass assessments in French and mathematics, like students from all over France. For the ministry, it is a matter of determining the level of students before college. A test that provokes the anger of teachers and unions. For teachers, this assessment comes too soon. The unions fear the establishment of a list, which the minister disputed Parents fear that the results will be used as a selection tool for entry to college.
Interviewed by Roland Sicard, the Minister of National Education Xavier Darcos returns to the objectives of the assessments of CM2 students in primary education. Some teachers are against it because they fear a ranking of schools and have said they do not want to pass the tests to their students.
Hélène Carrère d'Encausse, a university professor at Sciences Po, criticises the assessment tests for primary school pupils in the third and sixth grades. She thinks that the French education system is remarkable and that the assessments could have been done by the teachers themselves rather than being reduced to simple intermediaries. For her, the difficulties of the French education system and the results of these tests are well known. The question is why the education system has achieved such results.
In Blanquefort, as in all schools in France, students entering the third grade participate in assessment tests in reading, writing and mathematics. Interviews of the teacher on the course of the assessments. Another teacher warns about the differences from one student to another: "It is a decoy to want to believe that a child learns to read at six and in one year (...) there are children who in one year have acquired reading, other children for whom it takes two years." Some unions are also warning of the dangers of a two-tier school.
All students of CE2 and 6th today take assessment tests in French and mathematics. These tests are done to detect the difficulties of children in fundamental subjects, French and mathematics. Interviews with Jeanine Brindeau, departmental inspector, Alain Pauvereau, teacher and children who have just passed the tests.
A new system has been set up to assess the level of CE2 students in mathematics and French at the beginning of the year. Interview with Gérard Duthy on evaluations that should be support to help children and not an exam and with Michèle Lepy, teacher who welcomes this initiative: "This will perhaps give us more specific information that will allow us to move towards exercises that will better help children..."