What is the church’s position on homosexuality? Taboo or not? For decades the subject has been burning. Here the reactions of church people, testimonies in France but also in the Vatican.
Testimonies of practicing homosexual Christians: Jean-Marc became an Anglican at the age of 39. He left the Catholic Church because of its intolerance of homosexuality: "I lived hidden. I was a bit of a shameful faggot... what I was looking for was to be able to live in a church where I could live transparently," he explains in an Anglican church interview. Unlike Jean-Marc, Dominique and Michel, who have been in a relationship for 10 years, try to reconcile their faith, their membership in the Catholic Church and their love life. "If I left the Catholic Church, what I have no desire to do...it would be impoverishment for her. I am an opportunity for the Church," says Dominique. "My faith is direct with Jesus, with the gospel, with God and the hierarchy does not concern me too much. I feel left out of the Catholic Church anyway," adds Michel.
Report devoted to the text of the prayer to Mary addressed to the Evècs of France for the Ascension and which is controversial, because the text is pronounced against homosexual marriage. Interviews with parishioners at the exit of the church of Grandvilliers in Oise and Father Rémi HUBLIER, vicar general of the diocese of Beauvais who explains: "Basically, through bills for example, it really touches on something of the foundation of society and how we are all involved and that we look at the consequences of the choices that could be made... "
During a gathering of pilgrims of the current described as fundamentalist (Fraternity Saint Pius X), a loan affirms that as Catholics, they are against abortion, homosexual couples and adoption by same-sex couples.
The Instruction of the Catholic Church has just drafted a text in which it condemns homosexuality. It prohibits the ordination of homosexual priests. Interview with Bishop Tony ANATRELLA, Vatican consultant:" For the Church, homosexuality is a structural inconsistency of human sexuality, it is therefore incompatible with the priesthood". Interview of Daniel DUIGOU, priest and psychoanalyst: "I believe that we are facing an institution that has decidedly trouble to leave the Middle Ages...".
Gay pride 2000 is organized in Rome despite the hostility of the Vatican and part of Italian society. Voices have been raised in Rome, such as those of far-right activists and religious organizations. Interview with Imma BATTAGLIA, organizer of the World Gay Pride 2000: "We Italians, live in this country hyprocrite, bigot and dond this Gay pride will be the beginning of a new era...". of Cardinal Erzillio TONINI: "We do not choose the Holy Year, the Jubilee Year, we do not choose Rome, nor the Colosseum, it obviously becomes a provocation".
Martine, a Catholic homosexual woman, is part of the association "David and Jonathan", which brings together Christian homosexuals wishing to live their sexuality and their faith. She testifies with emotion about the Catholic Church that does not accept a homosexual life. "You can’t avoid living a gay life when you’re gay. We have to live what we are," she says. She evokes Monsignor Gaillot as a support, considers that homosexuals have as many problems as heterosexuals unmarried vis-à-vis the Church. She regrets that the homosexual couple is not recognized and finds that it is even harder for women.
Father Gérard DEFOIS, Secretary General of the French Episcopate, gives the Catholic Church’s view on homosexuality: "...one of the dangers at the present time is that homosexuality should be recognized as a kind of uncontrolled freedom for minors and on this point, because it goes to the nature of man and the dignity of sexuality, the Church wishes very strongly to say that it is not possible, moreover the WHO goes in this direction, to recognize for a standard what is, in our opinion, a kind of drift".
Philippe Harrouard interviews Bishop LHEUREUX, Bishop of Perpignan, on the position of the Church and the remarks of Pope John Paul II, who is very opposed to homosexuality/ MGR LHEUREUX does not regret his remarks on homosexuality made five years ago during an interview on the radio, He had been overwhelmed by the flood of reactions (insults but also moving confidences). This is a subject that remains very difficult to address probably because there is still a certain taboo that prevents us from talking calmly about homosexuality. He adds that two things must be said: "...homosexual physical relationships cannot fit within the moral tradition of the Christian church and it is not morally possible to accept them" but beyond the moral condemnation we must consider that there are many men and women who have not chosen their homosexual status and we must try to help them to live normally, to live as Christians. You have to make an effort to meet them." ... it is possible to live with great dignity ... a difficult situation which is that of homosexuals".