Eric Besson, Minister of Immigration, Integration, National Identity and Solidarity Development, answers questions from an auditor about the rationale for the debate on national identity and the notion of good or bad French.
François Bayrou criticises the electoral exploitation of the debate on national identity, saying that the great peoples do not question their identity in this way and that this risks dividing the French. He points out that the immigration, whose cause is often to be found in the misery of poor countries, concerns many French people who themselves come from immigration.
Alain Juppé gives his point of view on the debate on national identity at the initiative of Eric Besson. The mayor of Bordeaux believes that the debate risks pitting communities against each other, and instead encourages dialogue and mutual understanding.
Topic devoted to the controversy and split caused by the Great Debate on National Identity initiated by the Minister of Immigration, Eric Besson, Giving to hear the divergent opinions of various representatives of the political class including Dominique de Villepin in the program entitled "Les 4 vérités" of France 2 and interviews with the National Secretary of the PCF Marie-George Buffet and the UMP deputies Claude Goasguen and Jean-FrançoisFrançois Lamour.
From La Chapelle en Vercors, a high place of resistance against the Nazis, the president of the Republic defended his debate on national identity. Nicolas Sarkozy: "By force of abandonment, we ended up not knowing very well who we were. By cultivating self-hatred, we have closed the doors of the future. That is why, my fellow citizens, we must speak of our national identity... France is a country where there is no place for the burqa." The Socialist Party refuses this debate and the National Front opposes it. Benoît Hamon: "I don’t think the national identity is threatened by the burqa or by 350 to 500 burqas. National identity is threatened when one is not able, as the president of the Republic, to respect the values of freedom, equality, brotherhood. When a policy breaks the public service, when a policy does not ensure the equality of the French vis-à-vis the exit from the crisis". Marine Le Pen: "Today, I see that the president of the Republic does not answer any of the big questions that are asked daily and that rot the life of the French, the retreat of secularism, the development of the Communitarianism".
Eric Besson, Minister of Immigration, wants to launch a debate on national identity, a concept that is part of the remit of his ministry and which came out of the presidential campaign of Nicolas Sarkozy in 2007. Associations, unions, teachers and local elected officials among others should be involved in this reflection and that the socialist party already announces "without complacency"...
National identity has become one of the major themes of the presidential campaign since Nicolas Sarkozy advocated a ministry for national identity and immigration and Ségolène Royal advocated that every citizen should have a tricolour flag at home. The historian Max Gallo analyses the reason for this theme, which is now at the heart of electoral issues.
The theme of national identity is increasingly central to the debate in the 2007 presidential campaign. According to François Bayrou, the UDF candidate, the ideas of Jean-Marie Le Pen seem to influence this campaign. It expresses its desire to maintain a balanced and serene relationship with the nation.
Meeting with François Bayrou, UDF candidate for the presidential election, during his trip to Saint Denis, in the suburbs of Paris. He reacted in particular to the recent comments of Nicolas Sarkozy, UMP candidate, on the creation of a ministry of immigration and national identity: "National identity is not the business of a ministry... it is called Freedom Equality Fraternity".
François Bayrou, UDF candidate for the presidential election, reacted strongly to the statement by Nicolas Sarkozy, UMP candidate, regarding the creation of a ministry of immigration and national identity. According to François Bayrou, one of the first principles of the French Republic is that the nation is not based on race. He concludes by saying: "Let’s really get rid of these miasmas in the election campaign".
When questioned by Alain Touraine, Jacques Chirac, the candidate for the 1995 presidential election, details the values of French cultural and national identity, those he intends to defend during his term because, according to him, They are threatened, for example, social integration and cohesion.